Analysis: Fowle was North Korea's easiest US case
By ERIC TALMADGE, Associated Press
Oct 22, 2014 8:39 AM CDT
FILE - In this Sept. 1, 2014 file photo, Kenneth Bae, an American tour guide and missionary detained in North Korea, serving a 15-year sentence, speaks to The Associated Press in Pyongyang, North Korea. Why did North Korea free Jeffrey Fowle, and only him, when two other Americans, Bae and Matthew...   (Associated Press)

PYONGYANG, North Korea (AP) — Why did North Korea free Jeffrey Fowle, and only him, when two other Americans remain in prison there? Probably because Pyongyang considered him the most minor of the three offenders, and may believe that releasing him could improve abysmal U.S. relations and even temper growing international criticism of its human-rights record.

Fowle was not accused of espionage or "hostile acts," as the other Americans were. The 56-year-old was detained for six months for leaving a Bible in a nightclub in the city of Chongjin, where he was visiting with a foreign tour group.

He was flown out of North Korea on Tuesday, on a U.S. military jet that two Associated Press journalists spotted at Pyongyang's international airport. He was whisked to the U.S. territory of Guam before reuniting with his family early Wednesday at an Air Force base in Ohio.

His release follows a number of appeals recently from the North Korean government for Washington to take steps to resolve the matter. As part of its campaign to keep the issue on Washington's radar, Pyongyang allowed Fowle and the other two detainees to meet with the AP and other media several times to discuss their predicament and plea for help from their government.

Fowle, whose case never went to trial, said he left the Bible at the nightclub on an impulse, and later regretted it. Christian evangelism can lead to harsh punishment and even prison time in North Korea, but Fowle was not seen as having planned out any larger, systematic attempt to violate North Korean laws.

That is not the case with Matthew Miller and Kenneth Bae, who are serving lengthy sentences.

U.S. officials had no immediate comment on whether any progress toward releasing Miller or Bae has been made.

The North's official Korean Central News Agency said Fowle's release was a "special measure" by leader Kim Jong Un, "taking into consideration the repeated requests" of President Barack Obama. The KCNA report provided no updates on the other two men.

Miller, who like Fowle entered the country on a tourist visa, ripped up the document at Pyongyang's airport on April 10 and demanded asylum. But North Korean authorities claim he intended to conduct espionage. He was convicted and sentenced to six years in prison. During his brief trial six weeks ago, North Korean prosecutors said he admitted to the "wild ambition" of experiencing prison life so that he could secretly investigate North Korea's human rights situation.

Late last month, he told the AP he was digging in fields eight hours a day and being kept in isolation.

Bae, 46, has been held since November 2012, when he was detained while leading a tour group in a special North Korean economic zone. He was sentenced to 15 years in prison for "hostile acts" after being accused of smuggling in inflammatory literature and trying to establish a base for anti-government activities at a border city hotel. Bae is a Korean-American missionary, and his family believes he was detained because of his Christian faith.

Bae is suffering from chronic health issues, including back pain, diabetes, an enlarged heart and liver problems. He has said he feels abandoned by the U.S. government.

Both Miller and Bae told the AP they believe their only chance of release is the intervention of a high-ranking government official or a senior U.S. statesman. Previously, former Vice President Al Gore and former President Jimmy Carter have come to Pyongyang to bring detainees back home.

North Korea's calculus in releasing Fowle probably reflects several larger concerns.

North Korea is trying to counter criticism of its human-rights situation following the release earlier this year of a groundbreaking U.N. report laying out the regime's widespread abuses against its own citizens. The European Union and Japan have been pushing a U.N. resolution to refer North Korea to the International Criminal Court, and Pyongyang doesn't want the issue to even get to a vote.

Additionally, relations between Washington and Pyongyang are particularly bad, raising the possibility that the U.S. could strengthen its sanctions against the North or call on its allies to clamp down harder.

On Tuesday, North Korea's state-run Rodong Sinmun newspaper described relations with the U.S. at "the lowest ebb" since a 1994 diplomatic agreement between the two nations. Tuesday marked the 20th anniversary of that protocol, which froze Pyongyang's nuclear weapons program in return for the provision of nuclear power reactors and the eventual normalization of ties with the United States.

The protocol has since unraveled. Subsequent aid-for-disarmament negotiations involving the U.S., North Korea, South Korea, Japan, China and Russia have been stalled since 2008. The newspaper editorial Tuesday spoke of a "hostile policy" of the U.S. and said Washington should not oppose North Korea's nuclear deterrence.

Fowle's release could thus be seen as an attempt to feel out Washington and see if there is any possibility of broader talks.

Analysts say North Korea has previously used detained Americans as leverage, a contention that Pyongyang denies. Washington, too, has floated the possibility of a diplomatic opening should North Korea free the detainees.

U.S. State Department deputy spokeswoman Marie Harf said Fowle was seen by doctors and appeared to be in good health. She declined to give more details about his release except to thank the government of Sweden for its "tireless efforts." Sweden handles U.S. consular affairs in Pyongyang because the U.S. has no embassy there.

Harf would not say whether any American officials had intervened directly with the North Koreans.

"We'll let the North Koreans speak for themselves about why did they decide to do this," Harf said. "But we are pleased that he was able to leave, and urge the immediate release of the other two."

The United States has no diplomatic relations with North Korea and strongly warns American citizens against traveling to the country.

___

Eric Talmadge is the AP's Pyongyang bureau chief. Follow him on Twitter at twitter.com/EricTalmadge

See 2 more photos