Snappy newsletters. Simple Facebook sharing. Spirited comments. Sweet features are waiting… GET THEM NOW!

Economist: No To South Africa Sports Quotas

Athletic affirmative action ‘mocks’ merit in racially mixed nation

By Jonas Oransky,  Newser Staff

Posted Oct 25, 2007 5:53 PM CDT

(Newser) – The World Cup-winning South African rugby team shouldn’t be saddled with racial quotas, says the Economist: It’s exactly the wrong kind of affirmative action and would “mock the principle of merit.” One might think, the piece allows, the South African case would be the ultimate argument for quotas, as rugby “was a totem” of white nationalism during apartheid; but such move would actually hurts black athletes and the whole team.

The black athletes on the championship team contributed very little to the pitch, and quotas like those in provincial leagues would logically worsen the national squad. What’s more, many look askance at beneficiaries of affirmative action in South Africa’s business sector; they would presumably feel the same about athletes. Instead of quotas, the country should invest in aspiring black batsmen and pacers.

South African rugby fans react to the arrival of the Springbok team at Johannesburg's O. R. Tambo airport, Tuesday, Oct. 23, 2007.   A sea of green and gold greeted South Africa's victorious rugby team on its return home Tuesday after winning the Rugby World Cup in France. South Africa beat...
South African rugby fans react to the arrival of the Springbok team at Johannesburg's O. R. Tambo airport, Tuesday, Oct. 23, 2007. A sea of green and gold greeted South Africa's victorious rugby team...   (Associated Press)
South Africa's Springbok, rugby team captain John Smit, left, holding the William Webb Ellis trophy, with team mate Bryan Habana, right, wave to supporters on the teams arrival  in Johannesburg, Tuesday Oct. 23, 2007.  A sea of green and gold greeted South Africa's victorious rugby team on its return home...
South Africa's Springbok, rugby team captain John Smit, left, holding the William Webb Ellis trophy, with team mate Bryan Habana, right, wave to supporters on the teams arrival in Johannesburg, Tuesday...   (Associated Press)
South African rugby fans react to the arrival of the Springbok team at Johannesburg's O. R. Tambo airport, Tuesday, Oct. 23, 2007.   A sea of green and gold greeted South Africa's victorious rugby team on its return home Tuesday after winning the Rugby World Cup in France. South Africa beat...
South African rugby fans react to the arrival of the Springbok team at Johannesburg's O. R. Tambo airport, Tuesday, Oct. 23, 2007. A sea of green and gold greeted South Africa's victorious rugby team...   (Associated Press)
South African players celebrate at the final whistle of the Rugby World Cup final between England and South Africa at the Stade de France Stadium in Saint-Denis, near Paris, Saturday Oct. 20, 2007. South Africa won the match 15-6.  (AP Photo/PA, John Giles)
South African players celebrate at the final whistle of the Rugby World Cup final between England and South Africa at the Stade de France Stadium in Saint-Denis, near Paris, Saturday Oct. 20, 2007. South...   (Associated Press)
South Africa's Percy Montgomery, left, and South Afrcia's President Thabo Mbeki, pose with the trophy in the dressing room after their Rugby World Cup final win against England at the Stade de France Stadium in Saint-Denis, near Paris, Saturday Oct. 20, 2007. (AP Photo/Pool)
South Africa's Percy Montgomery, left, and South Afrcia's President Thabo Mbeki, pose with the trophy in the dressing room after their Rugby World Cup final win against England at the Stade de France...   (Associated Press)
South Africa's JP Pietersen, Percy Montgomery and Bryan Habana, from left, celebrate with the trophy after the Rugby World Cup final against England at the Stade de France Stadium in Saint-Denis, near Paris, Saturday Oct. 20, 2007. (AP Photo/Bernard Papon; Pool)
South Africa's JP Pietersen, Percy Montgomery and Bryan Habana, from left, celebrate with the trophy after the Rugby World Cup final against England at the Stade de France Stadium in Saint-Denis, near...   (Associated Press)
England fullback Jason Robinson is tackled by South African players Bakkies Botha and Fourie Du Preez during the Rugby World Cup final match between England and South Africa at the Stade de France stadium in Saint Denis, outside Paris, Saturday Oct.20, 2007. South Africa won 15-6. (AP Photo/Mark Baker)
England fullback Jason Robinson is tackled by South African players Bakkies Botha and Fourie Du Preez during the Rugby World Cup final match between England and South Africa at the Stade de France stadium...   (Associated Press)
England flyhalf Jonny Wikinson makes a unsuccessfull attempt at a drop goal as South African player Butch James left, attempts to charge it down during the Rugby World Cup final match between England and South Africa at the Stade de France stadium in Saint Denis, outside Paris, Saturday Oct.20,...
England flyhalf Jonny Wikinson makes a unsuccessfull attempt at a drop goal as South African player Butch James left, attempts to charge it down during the Rugby World Cup final match between England...   (Associated Press)
South Africa's players celebrate with the winner's trophy after the Rugby World Cup final between England and South Africa, Saturday, Oct. 20, 2007 at the Stade de France in Saint-Denis, north of Paris. South Africa defeated England 15-6.  (AP Photo/Francois Mori)
South Africa's players celebrate with the winner's trophy after the Rugby World Cup final between England and South Africa, Saturday, Oct. 20, 2007 at the Stade de France in Saint-Denis, north of Paris....   (Associated Press)
Jonny Wilkinson of England, center, passes the ball as he is being tackled by CJ Van der Linde, left, and Fourie du Preez, both of South Africa, during the Rugby World Cup final between England and South Africa, Saturday, Oct. 20, 2007 at the Stade de France in Saint-Denis, north...
Jonny Wilkinson of England, center, passes the ball as he is being tackled by CJ Van der Linde, left, and Fourie du Preez, both of South Africa, during the Rugby World Cup final between England and South...   (Associated Press)
South African inside back Francois Steyn right, makes a break upfield as England's Jonny Wikinson left, reaches out for the tackle during the Rugby World Cup final match between England and South Africa at the Stade de France stadium in Saint Denis, outside Paris, Saturday Oct.20, 2007. South Africa...
South African inside back Francois Steyn right, makes a break upfield as England's Jonny Wikinson left, reaches out for the tackle during the Rugby World Cup final match between England and South Africa...   (Associated Press)
« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow
To report an error on this story, notify our editors.
A snapshot of the day's best news stories.
 
COMMENTS
Be the first to comment on this story.

More Newser Stories

Rugby Star Charged With Axe Murders

Letters Show Jailed Mandela's Anguish

Memos: Israel Offered to Sell Nuclear Weapons to South Africa

Boy, 15, Admits White Supremacist Murder

Anti-Gay 'Dr. Shock' Busted on Sex Charges


NEWS FROM OUR PARTNERS
Other Sites We Like:   24/7 Wall St.   |   Betty Confidential   |   BuzzFeed   |   Cracked   |   Fark   |   Timelines   |   The Frisky   |   Geek Sugar   |   NewsOne