Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

September 7, 2008 12:21:21 AM CDT

Learn about Newser Points »

« Back to the grid | Next story »

Rudy the Dragon Slayer? Not Quite

Posted Dec 8, 07 9:23 AM CST in Politics 

(Newser) – Rudy Giuliani's campaign pitch presents him as nothing less than the savior of New York, the only man tough enough to tame the big bad city. Not surprisingly, not all New Yorkers buy it, writes Chris Smith of New York. “It’s insulting to every New Yorker that he goes around the country talking as if he thinks he was the animal tamer and we were the animals,” says former Mayor Ed Koch.

Examining Giuliani's legacy, Smith finds plenty of places where Rudy's pitch is "more myth than reality." Giuliani did, in fact, make an "enormous" contribution to the city's recovery, he writes, but more so in attitude than policy. Many of his bragging points, crime in particular, were the result of national trends largely out of his control.

Source New York

0 comments | Print E-mail | Digg Seed this on Newsvine Add this link to Del.icio.us StumbleUpon

Related Newser Stories

  • Why Rudy Fell So Far, So Fast

    Jan 30, 08 7:05 AM CST
    Why Rudy Fell So Far, So Fast How did the man who took summer polls by storm fall so precipitously in the esteem of GOP voters that he was finished by Florida, the state he chose for his first big victory? It could be the hubris, the inexperienced campaign team, the strategic mistakes—or it could be that "the more Republican voters saw of Mr. Giuliani, the less they wanted to vote for him," conclude Michael Powell and Michael Cooper in the New York Times. More »

  • Rudy Rooted in Saints, Sinners

    Nov 26, 07 6:42 AM CST
    Rudy Rooted in Saints, Sinners In search of what moral influences made the Rudy Giuliani we see today, Newsweek explores the pol's past and finds a boy with both cops and crooks in his family. The clash between Rudy's Catholic education and a father who served prison time, the mag writes, might explain his obsession with scofflaws and blindness to Bernard Kerik’s misdeeds. More »

  • Rudy Would Outdo W on Power Grab

    Oct 30, 07 12:51 PM CDT
    Rudy Would Outdo W on Power Grab Rudy Giuliani’s record in New York shows a leadership philosophy built on overlooking rules, says Washington Monthly’s Rachel Morris. Should the GOP frontrunner end up in the Oval Office, he would seize even more executive power than his assertive predecessor, Morris predicts. More »

  • Mexican Fence & More Guards Will Stop Illegals: Rudy

    Oct 25, 07 7:13 PM CDT
    Mexican Fence & More Guards Will Stop Illegals: Rudy Republican White House candidate Rudy Giuliani said that if he's elected president he would stem the flow of illegal immigrants into the country by building a high-tech fence along the Mexican border, boosting patrols 50% and stationing guards at 50-mile intervals. "You can stop them at the border," he told a town hall meeting in Iowa. More »

  • Rudy After 9/11: Take Me Out to the Ballgame

    Aug 18, 07 10:45 AM CDT
    Rudy After 9/11: Take Me Out to the Ballgame GOP presidential candidate Rudy Giuliani, who likes to capitalize on the hours he clocked at Ground Zero after 9/11, actually spent more time with the Yankees than he did with rescue workers, Salon reports. In a 40-day period following 9/11 Giuliani spent some 58 hours traveling to games, watching them and partying with his beloved Yankees, who made the World Series that year. More »

Mayor Rudy Giuliani, Gov. George Pataki and police chief Bernard Kerik get ready for a press conference in this file photo.   (Getty Images)
Rudy Giuliani throws out a first pitch for his beloved Yankees.   (Getty Images)
New York City in 1995: Mayor Rudolph Giuliani dances with his then wife, Donna Hanover, among revelers in Times Square on the 50th anniversary of V-J day.   (Magnum Photos)
« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow
Our editors also recommend:

Threads (1 of 1)

Tags

Rudy Giuliani  • New York City  • family values  • Ed Koch


Loading...

Premium Articles from HighBeam

Find more articles like this

Today's Most Popular


Other Politics Stories

What is Newser?

2008 Codie Finalist

Newser gives you more news in less time. We search for the best and most important stories all over the web, read them for you, and deliver concise and sharp summaries—along with links to the full text. Newser provides a way to stay on top of an ever-expanding horizon of news and opinion—politics, sports, business, trends, technology, personalities, crimes, and controversies. Newser keeps you not just better informed, but, with our signature graphic interface and smart condensed format, more enjoyably informed.

Learn more »