Peyton Who? Colts to Pick Andrew Luck Stanford quarterback will replace Manning: Indianapolis Star, ESPN By John Johnson, Newser Staff Posted Apr 19, 2012 1:13 PM CDT 5 comments Comments Stanford quarterback Andrew Luck will play for the Colts next season, reports the Indy Star. (AP Photo/Paul Sakuma) (Newser) – Drinking game for next week's NFL draft: Tip one every time the phrase "big shoes to fill" is used in reference to the No. 1 pick: The Indianapolis Colts have decided to select Stanford quarterback Andrew Luck, report ESPN and the Indianapolis Star. Luck, of course, will replace Peyton Manning, now with the Broncos. No pressure or anything.