Bill Murray Soars as FDR
But 'Hyde Park' itself isn't so hot, say critics
By Newser Editors, Newser Staff
Posted Dec 7, 2012 12:42 PM CST
Loading... Please wait

(Newser) – Bill Murray is getting generally strong reviews for his portrayal of Franklin Delano Roosevelt in Hyde Park on Hudson, although the movie itself—which centers on FDR's relationship with his cousin and eventual mistress—is disappointing critics. The Week checks out some reviews and sums it up: "Murray is by far the best thing about Hyde Park on Hudson, but his performance isn't enough to make this strange, letdown of a biopic worth seeing." Some typical sentiment on Murray:

  • Rex Reed, New York Observer: "Let others slobber over Daniel Day-Lewis as Abraham Lincoln. ... At the center of the action, holding the pieces together with infectious dazzle, a droll Bill Murray simply seizes the center ring and holds one’s attention from beginning to end."
  • Peter Travers, Rolling Stone: "Ugh, please, are you kidding me?" he moans of the movie. But he calls Murray's performance Oscar-worthy, saying it "has all the layers the rest of the movie doesn't have at all."

Of course, not everyone is bowled over:

  • Dana Stevens, Slate: "I wish I could say that Bill Murray’s performance as FDR was so wonderful it transcended the material, but the truth is that Murray’s character never fully emerges from the fog (and neither does his accent, which takes a well-meant but painful stab at recreating FDR’s trumpet-like mid-Atlantic drawl)."
  • Manohla Dargis, New York Times: FDR cousin/lover Daisy Suckley's "dreariness is so persuasive that whenever Eleanor or Missy, another of Franklin’s lovers, charge in, you long to follow them into another film—one in which everyone really does live in interesting times."
  • Meanwhile, David Daley at Salon takes aim at Dargis' descriptions of "presidential pleasuring," asking "How do you describe the president getting a hand job, in the New York Times?" Thusly, as per Dargis: “The violins surge, the flowers bob, and, alas, so does the president.”
Click for more.

View 1 image
More From Newser
My Take on This Story
To report an error on this story,
notify our editors.
Bill Murray Soars as FDR is...
Show results without voting
You Might Like
Showing 3 of 4 comments
Dec 9, 2012 10:44 AM CST
Not as good as "Groundhog Day."
Dec 7, 2012 2:19 PM CST
If you can give Pacino an Oscar for Scent of a Woman and Newman an Oscar for The Color of Money after both gave many performances far more worthy, you can give Murray one for this. Don't even bother with the other noms, just give the man his damn shiny trophy.
Dec 7, 2012 1:18 PM CST
More sludge from the Hollywood septic-tank. And..."Daisy Suckley"? You know she had to be a Democrat.