Now, the Pope Benedict Conspiracy Theories
Sex scandal? Nazi history? Prophecy?
By Neal Colgrass, Newser Staff
Posted Feb 11, 2013 5:51 PM CST
In this Dec. 21, 2005 file photo, Pope Benedict XVI, sporting a fur-trimmed hat, waves to pilgrims upon his arrival in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican for his weekly general audience.   (AP Photo/Alessandra Tarantino, File)

(Newser) – With Pope Benedict suddenly announcing his resignation today, we've looked at his legacy and the process for choosing his replacement. Now—forgive us—we delve into the inevitable conspiracy theories that "explain" his resignation:

  • His Nazi History. Benedict has acknowledged he was forced to serve in the Hitler Youth during a "dark time" in his childhood. Now the Atlantic Wire has dug up Twitter users like Melanie Karin, who writes, "Resigning for health reasons! Yeah. That's it. Not because of anything scandalous like ... having a Nazi youth past."
  • Sex Scandal. Not only has a sex-abuse scandal rocked the Catholic Church, Pope Benedict is said to have personally approved an accused molester's transfer to therapy. One tweeter directed a curious Piers Morgan ("As a Catholic, I'm not buying this") to see an HBO documentary on the subject, Mea Maxima Culpa.
  • The Prophecy. Of course, there's a prophecy. A bishop named Malachy may have proclaimed in 1140 that the 111th pope—the one after Benedict—will reign during the downfall of the church. But as the National Review explains, Malachy's predictions were likely invented for political reasons.
  • Fatal Illness. "Italians are great conspiracy theorists, so they are all looking for other reasons why he may have quit," says a Telegraph reporter. "I think the most popular reason that people were coming up with was that they just think perhaps he is much more ill than we have been told."
  • Weight of Scandal. Not exactly a conspiracy, this theory holds that church scandals (like "Vatileaks") have been hard on Benedict's health. "It is difficult to imagine the degree of intrigue that is present in Rome," a longtime friend tells Der Spiegel.

See how one of Benedict's policies led to a topless protest.

View 1 more image
More From Newser
My Take on This Story
To report an error on this story,
notify our editors.
Now, the Pope Benedict Conspiracy Theories is...
Show results without voting
You Might Like
Showing 3 of 97 comments
Feb 13, 2013 6:21 AM CST
The reasons for Benedict's departure really has very little conspiracy flavoring. It's what follows now; the (Malachy) prophesy of the popes, and the next pope him-(or her)-self, that should be interesting. Even if you don't subscribe to such things as this, you really shouldn't miss it because the next pope is going to inherit a very difficult spot in time.
Feb 12, 2013 12:19 PM CST
Wow! Too much hate here! Look inside of yourselves and make some corrections! You folks are going to crash on the rocks of life! WAYYYY too much hate. Sign of sickeness within. Heal youreselves!
Feb 12, 2013 11:54 AM CST
(R) 2014 & 2016 Gov. RICK PERRY Report: Not quite completed, God tell Pope Benedict has NOT try hard enough to visit China where is the anti-Rome Catholic before he resigns. Pope Benedict has NOT found a St. Mary's University or a St. John's University in Hong Kong before he wants to retire sooner.