How Hospital Bills Are Killing the US
Trumped-up bills 'drive the federal deficit': Steven Brill of Time
By Neal Colgrass, Newser Staff
Posted Feb 25, 2013 4:30 PM CST
Updated Mar 2, 2013 8:00 AM CST

(Newser) – Getting Hodgkin's lymphoma was bad enough. Then Ohio resident Sean Recchi received his hospital bill: $83,900. You can blame his limited health insurance, but Steven Brill at Time looked behind the numbers to see why MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston charged so much. What Brill found: shocking markups that hiked prices by several hundred percent or more above cost. Queried about the markups, MD Anderson said their billing practices "are complex" and "similar to those of other major hospitals." Which is exactly what Brill found: "a uniquely American gold rush" of tax-exempt "nonprofit" hospitals across the US that are raking in huge bucks and handing administrators mega-salaries. Among his other findings:

  • Hospitals are forcing Americans to spend nearly 20% of GDP on health care—double the usual for developed countries—and more than the next 10 top-spending nations combined.
  • Each hospital's internal price list, or chargemaster, is far higher than what Medicare pays for health care. Advocates have started a cottage industry helping people understand and reduce their bills.
  • Brill uncovers huge markups from specific bills, like $4,000 for items like a blanket warmer, marking pen, and surgical gown. Recchi was billed $13,702 for medicine that cost MD Anderson only $3,000 to $3,500.
  • Brill's first solution: Bring all Americans under the Medicare umbrella, and charge wealthier Americans more for their medical care. At least Medicare forces hospitals to charge the proper rates. Only problem: A massive, single-payer overhaul like that won't happen anytime soon.
  • Solution No.2: Strengthen anti-trust laws to restrict the power of hospitals; this would give insurance companies more leverage to bargain over prices. Then tax hospital profits at 75%, and tack a surcharge on excessive non-doctor hospital salaries. And ban the chargemaster. Will any of this happen? Probably not, because hospitals are too powerful.
  • Brill's take on ObamaCare: It's good for certain things, like curbing some hospital-bill collecting and getting more people insured. But ultimately it's just bringing more customers into a grossly unfair marketplace.
Click for the full article.

More From Newser
My Take on This Story
To report an error on this story,
notify our editors.
How Hospital Bills Are Killing the US is...
Show results without voting
You Might Like
Showing 3 of 129 comments
Jan 26, 2014 5:34 PM CST
I had a catherization done. Took 4 hours. Got bill: $16,000. $4,000/hour. Outrageous!!! Greed, greed, greed. I pay them $10/month and will never pay them off. I won't live long enough to pay them off.
Mar 13, 2013 1:28 PM CDT
Hospital bills aren't killing us, greed in general and within healthcare organizations is killing us. We constantly hear, "How are going to pay for healthcare!" when the real question is, "why is it so disproportionately fucking expensive in the first place?"'s not hospital bills that are killing us, its GREED.
Mar 6, 2013 8:29 AM CST
The Hospital / Insurance/ Pharmeceutical industry are a few of those corporations that continue to make the big profits. Small businesses are going belly up but Groceries , Gasoline, Automobiles, etc. are all making huge profits. Everyone under the thumb of the corporations. This is the future of America. The recorded voice with the numbered option list on your touch tone phone. Press one for English.