Monsanto Defeats Farmer in Soybean Patent Case
Supreme Court rules farmers can't grow second crop from patented seeds
By Ruth Brown, Newser Staff
Posted May 13, 2013 3:12 PM CDT
Vernon Hugh Bowman, a 75-year-old Indiana soybean farmer, speaks with reporters outside the Supreme Court in Washington.   (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)

(Newser) – Sometimes Goliath beats David—or Vernon, as the case may be. Seventy-six-year-old farmer Vernon Hugh Bowman has lost his Supreme Court battle with Monsanto over his use of patented soybean seeds, the New York Times reports. The court upheld an $84,000 lawsuit brought against Bowman by the agribusiness giant for growing and saving its seeds without paying a fee. Bowman had obtained the seeds from a grain elevator intended for animal feed, and argued that a doctrine called "patent exhaustion" allowed him to do as he pleased with the grain once he had purchased it. This may be true if he wanted to eat the seeds, but Justice Elena Kagan ruled that it does not extend to growing more seeds and replanting them without paying Monsanto for their use.

But this case was about more than a few soybeans. Other industries with self-replicating products—from biotechnology to software—were paying close attention to see if their patents would remain safe, USA Today reports. But Kagan warned the outcome of this one case did not necessarily assure their futures. "Our holding today is limited," she wrote. "We recognize that such inventions are becoming ever more prevalent, complex, and diverse. In another case, the article's self-replication might occur outside the purchaser’s control. Or it might be a necessary but incidental step in using the item for another purpose."

More From Newser
My Take on This Story
To report an error on this story,
notify our editors.
Monsanto Defeats Farmer in Soybean Patent Case is...
1%
4%
68%
3%
11%
13%
Show results without voting
You Might Like
Comments
Showing 3 of 34 comments
hopalong40
May 16, 2013 4:42 PM CDT
If you buy a car, and then, take the motor out, and put the motor in a tractor. You must pay GM a patent fee. The same thing as this story says. HOGWASH !!!!!!!!!
bewilderbeast
May 15, 2013 8:19 AM CDT
Monsanto: One of the world's most evil corporations. Nothing in fiction has ever been as shitty as this bunch.
NorCalHal
May 14, 2013 10:39 PM CDT
A company, or an individual, spends years and million or billions of dollars developing a product, technology or process and SOMEONE, whether another individual, company or nation, uses that information without paying the originator it's THEFT! I'm not a Monsanto friend or foe but if you want to use THEIR invention PAY FOR IT! Too bad the United States won't take China to the World Court for all it's patent infringement and theft of property - but then they might call some of their debt and the administration couldn't print money fast enough to pay (without outsourcing our mint to China) .