Mr. Peabody & Sherman Stays True to Original
Movie generally pleases, is charming with funny bits: reviews
By Arden Dier, Newser Staff
Posted Mar 7, 2014 11:44 AM CST
Loading... Please wait

(Newser) – Critics and audiences alike seem pleased with Mr. Peabody & Sherman, a remake of Jay Ward's classic cartoon—made famous on the Rocky & Bullwinkle Show—about a smart talking dog, his adopted human son, and their travels through history via their WABAC (think way-back) machine. What reviewers are saying:

  • Mr. Peabody & Sherman "is such a pleasant, mostly faithful surprise," Stephen Whitty writes for the Star-Ledger. It has "the original show's spirit, and some of its old-fashioned charm," which should give kids and parents alike "almost just as much giggly fun," even if it does leave the audience just a bit exhausted.
  • Colin Covert at the Minneapolis Star Tribune admits he had his doubts about a movie version of the 1960s show, but says, "I needn't have worried." The visuals have stepped up "to sleek 21st-century standards," and "the essential charm of the series survives more or less intact." Plus, "some of the archaic jokes are absolute crack-ups."
  • Betsy Sharkey agrees that "there's a smattering of harmless scatological sight gags likely to make everyone giggle," but says "the film may actually be too smart for its own good," she writes at the Los Angeles Times. "Many of Mr. Peabody's 'teaching moments' will sail right over the heads of kids while requiring adults to pay attention." Still, Ty Burrell's voicing of Mr. Peabody was "a genius choice."
  • Steven Rea agrees on Burrell, whom he calls "just right." The film is "a smart, snappy CG-animated adaptation" that is "true to the spirit of the original series," he writes at the Philadelphia Inquirer. And as a bonus, "the filmmakers inject a whooshy, propulsive sense of fun into the proceedings, too."

View 2 images
More From Newser
My Take on This Story
To report an error on this story,
notify our editors.
Mr. Peabody & Sherman Stays True to Original is...
1%
13%
1%
79%
1%
5%
Show results without voting
You Might Like
Comments
Showing 3 of 6 comments
FarmerMichael
Mar 9, 2014 1:32 AM CST
I've seen the 22 minute bit promoting it. I'm still not sold on the remake of Mr. Peabody. Too shinny skinned surfaces. I liked the old flat, more dog faced version. This is more like "The Incredibles" redo of Mr. Peabody. And what is with Sherman's Tweety Bird head? I'm glad they retain Jay Ward's humor in all this. The best cartoons are ones you loved as a kid and then see as an adult and go "wow, I missed half the jokes..."
People_Suck
Mar 9, 2014 1:04 AM CST
Another cartoon I liked was the turtle who was sent in time and always got in trouble then had to call "Mr. Wizthard"! to get him back through a vortex. Someone tell me the name because I can't remember.
viva_yo
Mar 8, 2014 1:58 PM CST
My favorite cartoons as a kid, the Rocky and Bulwinkle show. Loved those "Fractured Fairytales" especially. It was a really good kid's show, a lot like the newer British troop, "Horrible Histories" that provides some instruction with insane fun.