Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search
Newser - Current News - Breaking Stories

« Back to the grid | Next story »

Pundits Rate Near-Tie Debate

Posted Sep 27, 08 11:02 AM CDT in Politics,  Opinion 

(Newser) – One consensus is emerging about last night’s debate: It was close. Here’s how the pundits are calling the squeaker:

  • “Barack Obama was running for prime minister” last night, while McCain was running for president, writes David Ignatius in the Washington Post. But neither was compelling, and neither responded well to the economic crisis.
  • Fred Barnes of the Weekly Standard gives the win to McCain, “But the debate produced no knockout sound bites,” he writes, and so won’t change the race.

  • In a debate about tactics and strategies, Obama acted strategically, sticking to big issues and “an overall vision for the country,” writes Joe Klein of Time, while McCain fought tactically, trying to pick fights over details and “personal obsessions” like earmarks.
  • We’ll remember this debate alongside Kennedy-Nixon, Reagan-Carter, and Clinton-Bush, writes James Fallow of the Atlantic Monthly. In each case a fresh, inexperienced candidate didn’t exactly win, but proved himself a plausible president. 

Sources: Washington Post, The Weekly Standard, Time, The Atlantic

6 comments | Print E-mail | Digg Seed this on Newsvine Add this link to Del.icio.us StumbleUpon

Related Newser Stories

  • Bizarre Political Moments of '08

    Jan 2, 09 5:59 PM CST
    Bizarre Political Moments of '08 Oh-eight was a banner year for politics, and half the time it was a really strange banner. Politico looks back on the weirdest moments in a topsy-turvy year.

    • Mike Huckabee holds a news conference to announce he won’t run a negative ad, then plays the ad for everyone.
    • Desperate for blue collar cred, Hillary Clinton awkwardly downs a whiskey shot in an Indiana bar.
    • San Francisco tries to rename a sewage plant after George W. Bush.
    More »

  • Best Political Scoops of '08

    Dec 27, 08 9:19 PM CST
    Best Political Scoops of '08 Traditional media outlets and on-the-spot amateurs alike captured the year's biggest US political moments. Here is Politico's look at some of the biggest scoops:

    • Palin meets Couric: Interviewed by Katie Couric on CBS, Sarah Palin fumbled with softball questions such as which publications she reads. Democrats and Tina Fey pounced.
    • Edwards indulges: Major media outlets ignored a report of John Edwards' extramarital affair, but the National Enquirer caught him in the act.
    More »

  • Obama Gets Knocked for Bad Science

    Dec 27, 08 5:14 PM CST
    Obama Gets Knocked for Bad Science He’s about to lead the free world, but Barack Obama’s a little fuzzy on science,
    says a group that put the president-elect—along with John McCain, Tom Cruise, Oprah, and many others—on its celebrity list of shame. Obama’s offense? Suggesting that rising autism rates could be connected to vaccines despite a lack of evidence. More »

  • Obama Names 4 Top Science Advisers

    Dec 20, 08 12:23 PM CST
    Obama Names 4 Top Science Advisers Barack Obama today selected a Harvard physicist and a marine biologist for key science posts, in a sign he plans a more aggressive response to global warming than did the Bush administration. John Holdren and Jane Lubchenco are leading experts on climate change who have advocated forceful government action. “It's time we once again put science at the top of our agenda,” Obama said today. More »

  • Electoral College Needs Rehab

    Dec 15, 08 6:32 PM CST
    Electoral College Needs Rehab The 538 electors chosen to represent the will of the people cast their ballots for president today, officially ending the contest between Barack Obama and John McCain, writes Randall Lane for the New York Times. The otherwise-predictable ritual included a twist: a Nebraska elector voting for the candidate who won his congressional district (Obama), not the statewide vote (McCain). More »

Presidential debate moderator Jim Lehrer poses a question to Barack Obama and John McCain during the presidential debate Friday, Sept. 26, 2008 at the University of Mississippi in Oxford, Miss.   (AP Photo/Chip Somodevilla, Pool)
Barack Obama and John McCain shake hands with moderator Jim Lehrer after the presidential debate Friday, Sept. 26, 2008 at the University of Mississippi in Oxford, Miss.   (AP Photo/Chip Somodevilla, Pool)
« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow

The debate reinforced each man’s strengths and weaknesses. Obama had the most to lose, and he didn’t, so in that sense, he probably came out ahead. - David Ignatius

Winning isn't enough. To gain from a presidential debate, there must be sound bites that appear on TV day after day and show your opponent in an unfavorable or embarrassing light. - Fred Barnes

Ultimately, sadly, these debates are won, or lost, on style and perceptions of character—not substance. Those are matters of taste. - Joe Klein

The question was whether the challenger could stand as an equal with the more experienced, tested, and familiar figure. - James Fallow

« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow
Our editors also recommend:

Related Threads

(1 of 5)

Tags

Barack Obama • Election 2008 • John McCain • presidential debate • Jim Lehrer


Loading...