Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search
WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 25, 2009
| Subscribe to Newser's RSS feeds RSS | Follow Newser on Twitter Twitter


 ANALYSIS 
4

In Court, Philip Morris Uses Civil-Rights Smokescreen

Tobacco giant plays civil-rights card in battle with Oregon court over $79M judgment

Share

(Newser) – Philip Morris has cast itself as a civil-rights victim being denied due process, Stephanie Mencimer writes for Mother Jones. The tobacco giant, ordered by an Oregon jury in 1999 to pay $79 million in punitive damages to a woman whose husband died of lung cancer, has been fighting the award ever since, taking its case to the US Supreme Court three times.

The high court twice urged Oregon to lower the award but has been ignored. After the Oregon’s court latest maneuver sidestepping the order, Philip Morris likened its plight to that of the NAACP in a 1958 case in Alabama. The widow’s attorney called the strategy “brazen,” but she now faces a Supreme Court potentially irked at its snub from a lower court.

Philip Morris has been locked in a legal battle against a woman whose husband died from lung cancer in 1997, after smoking three packs of Marlboros a day for more than 40 years.
Philip Morris has been locked in a legal battle against a woman whose husband died from lung cancer in 1997, after smoking three packs of Marlboros a day for more than 40 years.   (AP Photo)
Mayola Williams, in wheelchair, widow of Jesse Williams, who died of lung cancer, leaves the Supreme Court in Washington.
Mayola Williams, in wheelchair, widow of Jesse Williams, who died of lung cancer, leaves the Supreme Court in Washington.   (AP Photo/Dennis Cook, File)
Mayola Williams, in wheelchair, widow of Jesse Williams, who died of lung cancer, leaves the Supreme Court in Washington.
Mayola Williams, in wheelchair, widow of Jesse Williams, who died of lung cancer, leaves the Supreme Court in Washington.   (AP Photo/Dennis Cook, file)
Philip Morris' victimhood dates back to 1999, when an Oregon jury hit the company with a $79 million punitive damages award in a lawsuit a smoking widow filed after her husband died.
Philip Morris' victimhood dates back to 1999, when an Oregon jury hit the company with a $79 million punitive damages award in a lawsuit a smoking widow filed after her husband died.   (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
A Marlboro cigarette leans against a pack of Marlboros cigarettes.
A Marlboro cigarette leans against a pack of Marlboros cigarettes.   (AP Photo/Mel Evans, file)
« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow

The verdict was a rare smoker's victory. For nearly 50 years, Philip Morris had defeated an endless string of personal injury lawsuits by waging a war of attrition on the plaintiffs.
- Stephanie Mencimer, Mother Jones

« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow
OFF THE GRID
11.24.09
Murdoch and Microsoft: The Mice Are Trying to Roar
11.23.09
Books Are Bad for You
4 comments
VIEWING:
 
Shannonals
Dec 5, 08 3:59 PM CST
Civil Rights for a Tobacco company? Reply
Vote up! Vote down!
0
PaleRider
Dec 5, 08 9:46 PM CST
Yea, it's Obama's Fault. Reply
Vote up! Vote down!
0
IN RESPONSE:
Shannonals
Dec 9, 08 10:20 PM CST
Feragola, do us all a favor, and cease making idiotic comments.
Vote up! Vote down!
0
AnnieOkie58
Dec 6, 08 10:03 AM CST
I personally dont think the Tobacco company should have to pay anything. We have all been told for many years...smoking is bad for our health, but some choose to ignore the warning...such as myself... Reply
Vote up! Vote down!
0
LEAVE A
COMMENT Comment Policy
Facebook ConnectPost this comment to Facebook?

After connecting you will have the option to post your comment on your Facebook profile.

 

Related Newser Stories

41 Stories

(AP) - Ruth Bader Ginsburg was released from a Washington hospital today after spending the night as a precaution. The 76-year-old Supreme Court justice planned to be back at work later today. Ginsburg, who underwent surgery for pancreatic cancer in February, "developed lightheadedness and fatigue" in her office yesterday after receiving... More »

MORE ABOUT:
cancer • Ruth Bader Ginsburg • Anemia • pancreatic cancer • US Supreme Court • Supreme Court justice

(Newser) - Australians may be coughing up $20 for a pack of cigarettes if officials approve a new anti-smoking plan, the Age reports. The proposal, designed to cut Aussie smoking by a third, would ban all tobacco sponsorship and online sales, devote 95% of cigarette packaging to graphic health warnings, and tax... More »

MORE ABOUT:
Australia • smoking • cigarettes • tobacco • Philip Morris • tobacco companies • cigarette tax

OPINION

Tobacco Bill's Winners: Philip Morris, Lawyers

We're smoking less because it's dumb, not because of policy: Will

Jun 18, 09 7:55 AM CDT
(Newser) - President Obama might have praised Congress' tobacco bill, but for George F. Will, the new legislation gives just two muscular groups reason to celebrate: Philip Morris and "the Democratic Party's fountain of funds, the trial bar." New restrictions on cigarette advertising will help Philip Morris vault over competitors,... More »

MORE ABOUT:
smoking • tobacco • Philip Morris • tobacco companies • cigarette tax • trial lawyers • cigarette

41 Stories


Supreme Court looks to preserve its authority over state courts
New York Times

Roberts mulls unprecedented plans to set the punitive award limit
Washington Post

Value of award now stands at $145M
Minneapolis Star Tribune


Crime & Courts 
TwitterFollow @NewserCrime on Twitter

 
cancer • smoking • Oregon • habeas corpus • Philip Morris • NAACP • tobacco companies • US Supreme Court

from our news partners