Flavored Cig Ban Is Silly: Kids Don't Smoke Them

What's more, FDA's claims about teen smoking are preposterous: Chapman

By Harry Kimball, Newser Staff

Posted Sep 29, 2009 11:28 AM CDT

(Newser) – The FDA is all over the map—and all wrong—with its ban on flavored cigarettes, writes Steve Chapman. The agency touts the move against the “gateway” tobacco products, saying it will break the cycle of addiction “for the more than 3,600 young people who start smoking daily.” First of all, kids don’t smoke fruity cigarettes. “Teenagers smoke because they want to seem older,” Chapman writes. “Smoking something that tastes like bubble gum sends the opposite signal.”

To wit, the FDA “doesn’t know” what percentage of teens smoked the fruity butts. But here's a statistic we do know: teen smoking is way down. One survey finds the number of high school seniors who smoke daily at its lowest level in 33 years, and down by almost 50% since the mid-1990s. So those 3,600 kids who start smoking every day? Poppycock. That many kids have their first cigarette daily, true. But "I smoked a couple of cigarettes in my youth,” Chapman writes in Reason. “I never ‘started smoking,’ any more than I ‘started speaking Chinese’ the one time I attended a Mandarin class.”

[Images (2)]

[Quotes (1)]

Flavored cigarettes. (AP Photo)

Clove cigarettes and cigars. (AP Photo)

« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow

Such cigarettes are more like the eye of a needle than a gateway. You would never know from the government's pronouncements that the nation's three major tobacco companies —R.J. Reynolds, Philip Morris, and Lorillard— don't even make them. - Steve Chapman

« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow

To report an error on this story, notify our editors.

More Newser Stories

FDA Whistleblowers: Our Email Was Monitored

Group of employees files lawsuit

(NEWSER) - A group of FDA scientists and doctors says that their personal emails were monitored by the agency after they acted as whistleblowers, and that the information gleaned from the surveillance led to their harassment or dismissal. The employees had complained internally, beginning in 2007, about approved or soon-to-be-approved cancer-screening devices that they believed posed risks to patients. Ultimately, they told Congress, the White House, and the Health and Human Services inspector general about their concerns, the Washington Post reports. More»

Feds Hit Red Cross With $9.6M Fine

FDA sites badly trained staff, poor record-keeping

(NEWSER) - The feds have slapped the American Red Cross with a $9.6 million fine for careless blood management practices, MSNBC reports. The FDA uncovered no actual harm to blood recipients, but expressed concern over poorly trained staff and slipshod record-keeping: We "cannot definitively say there was never any danger to the blood supply since the violations can create conditions that could lead to potential safety consequences,” an official said. More»

E-Cigs Work, But Have Smoking Foes Burning

They can help smokers quit, but anti-smoking groups still want ban

(NEWSER) - A recent experiment in Italy found that electronic cigarettes can help even hard-core smokers quit, boosting hopes that e-cigarettes could be a much better tool than more traditional products like nicotine patches and gum. So why are government officials and anti-smoking groups working to ban the device, which delivers a small amount of nicotine in an aerosol form? The New York Times takes an extensive look at the issue, and points out an odd reality: It’s the more liberal officials who are touting an "abstinence-only" policy when it comes to smoking cessation tools. More»

Judge Blocks Gruesome Cigarette Labels

Big Tobacco was likely to win First Amendment complaint

(NEWSER) - Wheeze out a sigh of relief, smokers of America: You won't have to look at a blackened lung or rotting teeth when you buy a pack of smokes next year after all. US District Judge Richard Leon blocked the new labels today, ruling that tobacco companies were likely to win their lawsuit claiming that they violated their First Amendment rights. Leon had previously held a hearing over the question of whether the graphic labels simply conveyed the facts about cigarettes' health risk, or constituted outright anti-smoking advocacy, the AP reports. More»

FDA Doctored Its Gross Cigarette Photos

That's one way to counter tobacco company lies!

(NEWSER) - The government has long accused those evil tobacco companies of running campaigns of deception to sell their products. Well, now the FDA is fighting fire with fire, Charles Hurt of the Washington Times has learned. The FDA has released a set of gruesome images that will soon be plastered on cigarette packs—and they are fabricated. “Some are photographs; some are illustrations,” a spokesman told Hurt. And good luck telling which is which. More»

NEWS FROM OUR PARTNERS

What is Newser?

Face it: there's too much news. At Newser, we choose the most thought-provoking and entertaining stories from hundreds of US and international sources and reduce them to a headline, picture, and two paragraphs. And we do it 24/7—you can come back morning, noon, night (and in between) for something new that matters. Read less, know more.

Learn more »

Partnering with: Slate

View Newser on the mobile website

Flavored Cig Ban Is Silly: Kids Don't Smoke Them