Dina Lohan recently accused ex-husband Michael of "beat[ing] the hell out of" her during their marriage, and said the reason daughter Lindsay is "so screwed up" is that she actually "saw her dad abuse me." Now, newly released photos obtained by Entertainment Tonight appear to back up Dina's story; they show a much younger Dina with a black eye—sometimes while holding a baby. But Michael tells ET his version of the story, which isn't much more pleasant: "[Dina] hit me with an ice tray, and I turned around and swung ... I didn't punch her. I didn't do anything deliberately to attack her. I swung out of reflex." Click to see the three photos.