Finally, Evidence of Other World That Helped Form Moon
Lunar rocks bolster a long-held theory about how the moon was created
By Elizabeth Armstrong Moore, Newser Staff
Posted Jun 6, 2014 8:28 AM CDT
Lunar rocks bolster a long-held theory about how the moon was created.   (AP Photo/Lauren Harnett - NASA)

(Newser) – A new analysis of three lunar rocks brought back by Apollo astronauts in the '60s breathes new life into an old theory some thought too simple: that the moon was created when another planet, Theia, crashed into Earth billions of years ago, leaving behind molten debris that eventually cooled and moved into a stable orbit around our planet. The problem is that, after numerous inspections of the rocks, no one could find any trace of another planet. Until now. Previous analysis of the samples found they were identical to samples from Earth, when they should have shown some difference to indicate they also came from Theia. But now, "we have ... discovered small differences between the Earth and the moon," the lead researcher tells the BBC. "This confirms the giant impact hypothesis."

The difference detected is tiny indeed—the lunar samples carry a barely detectable abundance of oxygen-17, a form of oxygen that has nine neutrons in its atoms instead of the typical eight. In fact, the lunar samples have just 0.012% more oxygen-17 than is found on Earth, but it's enough to suggest the involvement of another planet that also featured more of the element. Scientists spotted the difference using a novel technique, explains Time: They sealed the rocks in a chamber of fluorine gas, vaporized a small portion of the rocks with a laser beam, and drained out the gas and vapor, which were then sent through a device called a chromatograph to separate oxygen from the other gases. This also enabled them to spot the same difference in samples previous researchers had looked at and found no difference. (In other cool space news, astronomers recently discovered a planet with an 8-hour day.)

More From Newser
My Take on This Story
To report an error on this story,
notify our editors.
Finally, Evidence of Other World That Helped Form Moon is...
2%
31%
1%
48%
1%
18%
Show results without voting
You Might Like
Comments
Showing 3 of 47 comments
Enigmaticus-Paradoximus
Jun 9, 2014 3:21 PM CDT
Where is the planet which allegedly birthed the moon? "Science" continues to grasp at straws and leap to conclusions rather than embrace the simple fact that "In the beginning ..."
dan6807
Jun 7, 2014 11:23 PM CDT
O 17 is a decay product of nitrogen and fluorine gas. Did they use a vacuum chamber or test non - moon samples? I have to question this conclusion as the controls for such a finding would be very hard to create. Any nitrogen contamination would lead to increased O 17 production. Where were these "moon" rocks kept? At the National Archives along with the missing Apollo film perhaps?
TwoSheds
Jun 7, 2014 9:35 PM CDT
Dare I ask what is the margin of error in the samples?