Sorry, Charlie, time to pay up. StarKist is offering $25 in cash or $50 in free tuna to eligible consumers as part of a class-action lawsuit settlement worth a total of $12 million, the New York Times reports. Those who meet the qualifications—namely, that they're US residents who purchased a 5-ounce can of one of four varieties of the brand's tuna between Feb. 19, 2009, and Oct. 31, 2014—can file a claim online.
So what was fishy about the product to elicit this settlement? Plaintiff Patrick Hendricks claimed the company didn't fill the 5-ounce cans to capacity, and the independent testing he had done showed cans had 17.3% less tuna than the federally mandated minimum, the Times notes. Don't have your tuna receipts from 2009? The company is going on the honor system, under penalty of perjury, for those who file a claim, Consumerist reports. (Bumble Bee just settled its own tuna-related lawsuit, but this one was much worse.)