Guy Who Planned NYE Attack Was Panhandler: Bar Owner
Emanuel Lutchman 'caused more trouble than positive'
By Newser Editors and Wire Services
Posted Jan 1, 2016 12:52 PM CST
This undated photo provided by the New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision shows Emanuel Lutchman, of Rochester, NY.   (New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision via AP)

(Newser) – A western New York bar owner who says his restaurant was the one identified by authorities as the target of a would-be terrorist says the man arrested in the plot is an aggressive panhandler. The Democrat and Chronicle of Rochester reports that Merchants Grill co-owner John Page described Emanuel Lutchman, of Rochester, as a panhandler who "caused more trouble than positive." Federal authorities say the 25-year-old Lutchman sought to prove he was worthy of joining the Islamic State group by carrying out a New Year's Eve attack at a bar using a machete and knives provided by an FBI informant. He was arrested Wednesday. Authorities did not identify the bar, but Page said his restaurant was the supposed target.

Lutchman's former stepmother, Charma Lutchman, told the Democrat and Chronicle that Lutchman spent part of his childhood living with his grandparents in New York City. She said that while young, he was struck by a car, an accident that transformed him from a happy-go-lucky boy to a more withdrawn child. "He wasn't the same boy I knew after he got hit by a car," she said. "He was different, more quiet." Authorities said in court papers that Lutchman, 25, is a convert to Islam who said he received direction from an overseas Islamic State member. He was described in court papers as having long criminal history including a 2006 robbery conviction that led to a five-year prison sentence and arrests for mental health issues. The Democrat and Chronicle reports Lutchman spent four months in a Rochester jail in 2015 on misdemeanor charges of petit larceny and menacing his girlfriend.