The Arizona Republic—which was founded as the Arizona Republican in 1890, 22 years before Arizona became a state—broke with 126 years of history Wednesday by endorsing a Democrat over a Republican for president for the first time. "This year is different," the paper's editorial board wrote, citing Donald Trump's "deep character flaws" and questioning his conservatism. Hillary Clinton is a flawed candidate, but she is competent and does not "casually say things that embolden our adversaries and frighten our allies," the board wrote. "Her approach to governance is mature, confident, and rational."
The paper—which endorsed Benjamin Harrison in 1892 and carried on endorsing Republicans through to Mitt Romney in 2012, though it refused to endorse either Nixon or LBJ in 1968—faced a major backlash after the Clinton endorsement, with plenty of angry phone calls, subscription cancellations, and even a death threat, USA Today reports. Other papers, including the Cincinnati Enquirer, lost subscribers after failing to endorse Trump, but Republic editorial page editor Phil Boas says he believes the board made the right decision. "We think that we are being traditionalists here. We're saying we're not willing to compromise our values," he tells the New York Times.