Snappy newsletters. Simple Facebook sharing. Spirited comments. Sweet features are waiting… GET THEM NOW!

Hot on Facebook
Guy Buys $123 Safe on eBay, Finds $26,000 Inside Seller tries to get half the cash back, fails »

Which Came First: Quake or Collapse?

It's geologists vs. mine owner on cause of Utah disaster

By Heather McPherson,  Newser User

Posted Aug 8, 2007 5:19 PM CDT

(Newser) – A cave-in method of coal extraction called “retreat mining,” recently okayed by regulators for Crandall Canyon, was more likely to have caused the Utah mine disaster than an earthquake, seismographers tell the Los Angeles Times. And they say the massive tremor was consistent with the type  “induced by underground coal mining.” It “just doesn’t look like a natural event,” one says.

Still, a quake can't be ruled out, because they do occur at that magnitude in central Utah.
Robert Murray, president of company that operates the mine, insists that there was no retreat mining in the vicinity of the miners. The technique, which involves pulling out pillars made of coal as excavation is finished in an area, is notoriously dangerous; the last pillar to be pulled is nicknamed the "suicide pillar."

An aerial view of the Crandall Canyon Mine in Huntington, Utah,  where miners are trapped, is seen Monday, Aug.  6, 2007.  Efforts to reach six coal miners trapped more than 1,500 feet (457 meters) underground in Utah will take at least three days, and rescuers were not even sure...
An aerial view of the Crandall Canyon Mine in Huntington, Utah, where miners are trapped, is seen Monday, Aug. 6, 2007. Efforts to reach six coal miners trapped more than 1,500 feet (457 meters) underground...   (Associated Press)
Robert Murray, right, chairman of Murray Energy Corp. of Cleveland, a part owner of the Crandall Canyon mine speaks with the media about the ongoing efforts to save 6 miners trapped in the collapsed mine Monday, Aug. 7, 2007, in Huntington, Utah. Doug Johnson, left,  director of corporate services at...
Robert Murray, right, chairman of Murray Energy Corp. of Cleveland, a part owner of the Crandall Canyon mine speaks with the media about the ongoing efforts to save 6 miners trapped in the collapsed mine...   (Associated Press)
Mine equipment arrives to help in the rescue of six trapped coal miners at the entrance to his Crandall Canyon Mine on Monday, Aug. 6, 2007, northwest of Huntington, Utah. (AP Photo/Douglas C. Pizac)
Mine equipment arrives to help in the rescue of six trapped coal miners at the entrance to his Crandall Canyon Mine on Monday, Aug. 6, 2007, northwest of Huntington, Utah. (AP Photo/Douglas C. Pizac)   (Associated Press)
A map shows the Crandall Canyon Mine on Monday, Aug. 6, 2007, northwest of Huntington, Utah. Hundreds of rescuers broke through walls of rock Monday in a desperate race to reach six coal miners trapped 1,500 feet below ground by a cave-in at the Crandall Canyon mine. (AP Photo/Douglas...
A map shows the Crandall Canyon Mine on Monday, Aug. 6, 2007, northwest of Huntington, Utah. Hundreds of rescuers broke through walls of rock Monday in a desperate race to reach six coal miners trapped...   (Associated Press)
Robert E. Murray, founder and chairman of Murray Energy Corp, which owns the Crandall Canyon mine, announces that seismic activity has totally shut down efforts to reach six miners trapped below ground and has wiped out all the work done in the past day at a news conference Tuesday night,...
Robert E. Murray, founder and chairman of Murray Energy Corp, which owns the Crandall Canyon mine, announces that seismic activity has "totally shut down" efforts to reach six miners trapped below ground...   (Associated Press)
Robert Murray, founder and chairman of Cleveland-based Murray Energy Corp., speaks with a reporters following his update news conference on the rescue efforts for six trapped coal miners at the entrance to the Crandall Canyon Mine on Tuesday, Aug. 7, 2007, northwest of Huntington, Utah. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)
Robert Murray, founder and chairman of Cleveland-based Murray Energy Corp., speaks with a reporters following his update news conference on the rescue efforts for six trapped coal miners at the entrance...   (Associated Press)
Robert Murray, founder and chairman of Cleveland-based Murray Energy Corp., gives an update on the rescue efforts for six trapped coal miners during a news conference at the entrance to the Crandall Canyon Mine on Tuesday, Aug. 7, 2007, northwest of Huntington, Utah. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)
Robert Murray, founder and chairman of Cleveland-based Murray Energy Corp., gives an update on the rescue efforts for six trapped coal miners during a news conference at the entrance to the Crandall Canyon...   (Associated Press)
Robert Murray, founder and chairman of Cleveland-based Murray Energy Corp., gives an update on the rescue efforts for six trapped coal miners during a news conference at the entrance to the Crandall Canyon Mine on Tuesday, Aug. 7, 2007, northwest of Huntington, Utah. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)
Robert Murray, founder and chairman of Cleveland-based Murray Energy Corp., gives an update on the rescue efforts for six trapped coal miners during a news conference at the entrance to the Crandall Canyon...   (Associated Press)
Ariana Sanchez, 16, back to camera,  is comforted by a loved one,  as  Rogelio Bustillos,wearing hat,  comforts  Ariana's sister, Apolonia Sanchez  after they learned  that Manuel Sanchez, 42, the girls' father,  was among the miners  trapped   in the Crandall Canyon Mine. in Huntington Utah, Monday, Aug.  6,  2007.   Efforts...
Ariana Sanchez, 16, back to camera, is comforted by a loved one, as Rogelio Bustillos,wearing hat, comforts Ariana's sister, Apolonia Sanchez after they learned that Manuel Sanchez, 42, the girls'...   (Associated Press)
Miners load their gear after their shifts trying to rescue six trapped coal miners at the entrance to the Crandall Canyon Mine on Tuesday, Aug. 7, 2007, northwest of Huntington, Utah. (AP Photo/Douglas C. Pizac)
Miners load their gear after their shifts trying to rescue six trapped coal miners at the entrance to the Crandall Canyon Mine on Tuesday, Aug. 7, 2007, northwest of Huntington, Utah. (AP Photo/Douglas...   (Associated Press)
« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow
To report an error on this story, notify our editors.
A snapshot of the day's best news stories.
 
COMMENTS
Be the first to comment on this story.

More Newser Stories

6th Hole Shows No Signs of Life

Owners Mull Reopening Mine

Mine Rescue Effort Called Off

3 Rescue Workers Killed in Mine

9 Injured in 2nd Mine Collapse


NEWS FROM OUR PARTNERS
Other Sites We Like:   24/7 Wall St.   |   Betty Confidential   |   BuzzFeed   |   Cracked   |   Fark   |   Timelines   |   The Frisky   |   Geek Sugar   |   NewsOne