Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 24, 2009
| Subscribe to Newser's RSS feeds RSS | Follow Newser on Twitter Twitter


19

Twilight Scribe Accused of Plagiarism

Dueling vampire novels bear similarities, author says

Share

(Newser) Twilight author Stephenie Meyer is being accused of ripping off another vampire book, TMZ reports. Jordan Scott claims the series’ fourth installment, Breaking Dawn, bears a “striking and substantial similarity” to her 2006 book The Nocturne, with both including a post-wedding sex scene, a doomed pregnancy, and the death of the main character’s wife. Meyer and her reps deny any knowledge of Scott’s book.

After reading the cease-and-desist letter Scott sent Meyer’s publisher, however, the Cajun Boy is “unconvinced of any wrongdoing,” he blogs for Gawker. “You’d almost think that Scott thinks as though she’s the only writer to ever include a wedding, a death, and a sex scene in a novel, but go ahead and judge for yourself.” Read the letter at the link below.

In this image released by Summit Entertainment, Kristen Stewart, left, and Robert Pattinson are shown in a scene from
In this image released by Summit Entertainment, Kristen Stewart, left, and Robert Pattinson are shown in a scene from "Twilight."   (AP Photo)
This photo originally released by Little, Brown and Company shows author Stephenie Meyer.
This photo originally released by Little, Brown and Company shows author Stephenie Meyer.   (AP Photo/David Stone,Little,Brown and Company, file)
This photo released by Little, Brown Books For Young Readers shows the cover of
This photo released by Little, Brown Books For Young Readers shows the cover of "Breaking Dawn," by Stephenie Meyer.   (AP Photo)
« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow
19 comments
VIEWING:
 
ruserious
Aug 4, 09 10:17 AM CDT
This reminds me of when J.L. Rowling published Harry Potter. There was a woman that accused Rowling of stealing the name and a few ideas from her own book about a wizard named Larry Potter. I don't think it went anywhere, though. Reply
Vote up! Vote down!
+2
IN RESPONSE:
BoZo
Aug 4, 09 11:32 AM CDT
In 1990, long before Harry Potter, Neil Gaiman created a character called Tim Hunter in the comic book "Books of Magic". The similarities between Tim and Harry are far too blatant to ignore: they both have messy black hair and glasses, both were orphaned when they were babies, both have scars on their foreheads, both have owls as pets, both go to wizarding school, and both have the potential to be the geatest wizards in the world. If this isn't enough to assume that J.K. Rowling's idea for Harry Potter wasn't ripped from Neil Gaiman's character, I don't know what is.
Vote up! Vote down!
+4
IN RESPONSE:
Netstorm2k9
Aug 4, 09 12:34 PM CDT
Larry Potter. LOL. Set his ass in a trailer park.
Vote up! Vote down!
0
IN RESPONSE:
johntitor
Aug 4, 09 1:27 PM CDT
Its true, Neil is 800 times the storyteller Rowling will never be. I mean she has one plot device nearly every book. Kill off a character. You don't even have to know about sandman to respect Gaiman. Anyone see "stardust?"
Vote up! Vote down!
+2
BleeBloo
Aug 4, 09 10:45 AM CDT
ANYTHING, anything at all to get that horrible Stephanie Meyer to STOP WRITING her disgusting misogynistic tripe. Ugh. Reply
Vote up! Vote down!
+8
LEAVE A
COMMENT
Comment Policy
Facebook ConnectPost this comment to Facebook?

After connecting you will have the option to post your comment on your Facebook profile.