Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2009
| Subscribe to Newser's RSS feeds RSS | Follow Newser on Twitter Twitter


 OPINION 
10

Mukasey: Now's No Time to Weaken Patriot Act

Terror arrests show that national security needs trump privacy worries

Share

(Newser) – The arrests last week of Najibullah Zazi and other terror suspects should make lawmakers think twice about making intelligence-gathering more difficult for those trying to keep America safe from terrorist attacks, writes Michael Mukasey. Congressional Democrats are considering imposing new requirements on Patriot Act provisions when they come up for renewal later this year, Mukasey writes, but doing so has the potential to thwart terror investigations.

Tools like roving wiretaps are vital to terror investigations, the former attorney general writes in the Wall Street Journal, and requiring authorities to show proof of terror links before they can be obtained turns the whole concept of an investigation upside down. Those "who would roll back current authorities in the name of protecting civil liberties, should consider what legislation will be proposed and passed if the next Najibullah Zazi is not detected," Mukasey concludes.

Najibullah Zazi, center, is escorted off an NYPD helicopter by U.S Marshals after being extradited from Denver, Colo., last week.
Najibullah Zazi, center, is escorted off an NYPD helicopter by U.S Marshals after being extradited from Denver, Colo., last week.   (AP Photo/New York City Police Department)
Michael Mukasey addresses the American Bar Association's Standing Committee on Law and National Security, at the University Club in Washington.
Michael Mukasey addresses the American Bar Association's Standing Committee on Law and National Security, at the University Club in Washington.   (AP Photo/Gerald Herbert)
« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow

There is no sense in giving investigators in national security cases less authority than investigators in criminal cases, and in criticizing them for failing to connect the dots while denying them the authority to discover the dots. - Michael Mukasey

« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow
10 comments
VIEWING:
 
riffran
Oct 2, 09 6:35 AM CDT
slippery slope..at what point does it go from protection to invasion of privacy...They caught this one, but what if they didn't ....BOOM... Reply
Vote up! Vote down!
0
IN RESPONSE:
Bambi
Oct 2, 09 9:29 AM CDT
I don't think it's very slippery at all. Corrupt applications of a government mandate to override the constitution, even though it may at other times be used to save lives in some cases, is an even greater threat of deadly criminal force. How about the illegal campaigns against civil rights leaders and other high profile stuff like Nixon's persecution of John Lennon? Something like 'The Patriot Act' can be used as part of an anti-constitutional campaign to undermine political dissenters. Among the founding principles of our country--one of the defining characteristics of democracy--is the right to dissent. If you want to 'blame' someone for the need to eliminate the patriot act, you can blame those who have dishonored their offices through treachery and deception while holding power--the kind to whom The Patriot Act is wrapped in a bow, for it is they who created the mistrust , it is they who provided the evidence that greed and political self-preservation, for some politicians, will always take precedence over the good of the people over which they govern. It is they who have made it impossible to trust politicians to use such as tool only for 'good'. You can thank those guys, for their names are Nixon and Bush. Blocking future criminals like them from using tools like The Patriot Act to undermine dissent is MORE VALUABLE AND IMPORTANT than having the use of such a tool to help stop terrorist attacks. Governmental violation of our constitution is more deadly than any terrorist bomb could prove to be. In fact, the irony would be that the terrorist 'threat' will have lead to the erosion of our constitution's guarantees...what should satisfy a terrorist more, killing 75 people in a hotel lobby, or actually compromising our values, ideologies and our freedom as a nation. Some people are bent out of shape about flag burning, well, constitution burning (especially from within) should be taken much more seriously. Ironically the one's that make a big deal about the former, tend to approve the latter. Go figure!
Vote up! Vote down!
+5
SilenceDogood
Oct 2, 09 7:07 AM CDT
Where are all of the neo-Liberals screaming that GW Bush wire tapped America and shredded the Constitution? This may not be what we want, but it may be what we need. Law enforcement against a covert, imbedded, intelligent terrorist within these United States requires new methods. Traditional police work is catching a felon AFTER the crime is committed; in this case we need to stop the terrorists BEFORE people are killed by the murdering cowards. Reply
Vote up! Vote down!
-1
IN RESPONSE:
WallyEFunk
Oct 2, 09 8:49 AM CDT
I'm sure you had both conservatives and liberal not liking the "Patriot Act" The Oxymoron named law. Since it suspends what it's trying to protect.The slippery slope could continue.Would you want law enforcement to have these types power for all citizens? It would be great to stop someone before a person committed a crime. How can you control such a monster.Sounds like it's needed though! Only wish they had to go threw some grand jury,so that the PPL would choose to allow the government such power, possibly even more, on a case on a case investigation.
Vote up! Vote down!
+2
JaneMP
Oct 2, 09 9:10 AM CDT
How does anyone know that these cases were discovered because of this Bush invasion of privacy? Before the Patriot Act, law enforcement could get a warrant any time they wanted and could use the tap for 24 hours before the warrant was granted. We need that tiny bit of responsibility that existed before W tossed the Constitution away. Reply
Vote up! Vote down!
+2
LEAVE A
COMMENT
Comment Policy
Facebook ConnectPost this comment to Facebook?

After connecting you will have the option to post your comment on your Facebook profile.