NYers Saddest in US? Fuhgeddaboutit! Contentment is overrated, according to New Yorker By Rob Quinn, Newser Staff Posted Dec 22, 2009 4:30 AM CST 9 comments Comments An NYPD traffic officer directs traffic on Times Square in New York. (AP Photo/Dima Gavrysh) (Newser) – New York state came rock bottom out 50 states and DC in a recent study of happiness, prompting Clyde Haberman to ask not what's wrong with New York, but what's so great about happiness. "Might contentment be overrated?" he wonders in the New York Times. "Seriously, isn’t restlessness, even outright discontent, often a catalyst for creativity?" New York may be in last place, ranked by indicators like climate, cost of living, and crime rates, but there are more people living in New York City than ever before despite all that alleged unhappiness, Haberman notes. The top ten happiest states, meanwhile, include some of the poorest states in the country, like Alabama and Mississippi. "Are people there truly happy, or are they wearing “What, me worry?” smiles," Haberman wonders.