Wolfman Bites (in a Bad Way)
Movie is campy and dumb, though one critic enjoys anyway
By Kevin Spak,  Newser Staff
Posted Feb 12, 2010 9:04 AM CST
In this image released by Universal Pictures, Benicio Del Toro is shown in a scene from, "The Wolfman."   (AP Photo/Universal Pictures, Frank Ockenfels)
camera-icon View 1 more image

(Newser) – Critics aren’t exactly howling over the new remake of The Wolfman starring Benicio del Toro, giving it mostly mediocre or failing marks. Here’s what they’re saying:

  • “The movie is pungent with atmosphere, laying down a thick fog of creepy Victorian murk,” writes Kyle Smith of the New York Post, but the story is toothless, centering on a mystery “so simple that even Marmaduke could have sniffed it out.”

  • “The movie is scary only as regards all its wasted potential,” laments John Anderson of the Wall Street Journal. There are good elements here, but they’re “reduced to a gruesome fondue, accessorized by actorly ham and studio cheese.”
  • The filmmakers obviously loved the original Wolfman, but “nostalgia isn't always the best barometer,” writes James Berardinelli of ReelViews. The makeup is “inexcusably campy,” and scenes from the original are “recreated in a fashion that seems more Monty Python than unsettling.”
  • But Ty Burr of the Boston Globe had fun. “The movie is by no means good,” he writes, “but it’s surprisingly enjoyable: a misty, moody Saturday-matinee monster-chiller-horror special.”