Things turned ugly last night for Jimmy Kimmel when the "Handsome Men's Club" he founded—which included Rob Lowe, Ben Affleck, Ted Danson, Taye Diggs, and Josh Hartnett—booted him from his own society. Matthew McConaughey started the charge, with backup from Sting. John Krasinski rose to Kimmel's defense, but to no avail.
A 9-minute chunk of the post-Oscar episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live! presented the club meeting and its aftermath. Lenny Kravitz tried to back up Kimmel with a song that included a mention of "the supple breasts of a 14-year-old girl," but Kimmel was ousted anyway—or was he? New York has the video, which features a couple of dramatic twists and an A-list female guest star.