Skip to: Content
Skip to: Site Navigation
Skip to: Search

TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 9, 2010
 |  Follow Newser on Twitter   Friend Newser on Facebook   Subscribe to Newser's RSS feeds   Subscribe to Newser emails Newsletters


 OPINION 
77

It's Un-American to Pledge Allegiance to the Flag

We aren't medieval subjects serving feudal lords and kings

Share

(Newser) – Americans everywhere ought to applaud 10-year-old Will Phillips, who told his teacher to "go jump off a bridge" after doing what we all should do: criticizing the Pledge of Allegiance. Phillips argued that because gay marriage isn’t legal, there isn’t “liberty and justice for all”—but forget his specific complaint for a moment. “The very idea of the pledge of allegiance, in any form, is completely at odds with” American ideals, writes Michael Lind of Salon.

“The concept of ‘allegiance’ is feudal,” Lind explains. In America, as John Locke and Thomas Jefferson imagined it, we have only each other to pledge allegiance to. The government is merely a tool of our collective will. To the founders, pledging allegiance to the flag, or any other symbol of state, “would make about as much sense as pledging obedience to your refrigerator.”

Pledging allegiance to the government is as un-American as it gets.
Pledging allegiance to the government is as un-American as it gets.   (Shutterstock)
« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow

In a republic, the people should not pledge allegiance to the government; the government should pledge allegiance to the people. - Michael Lind

Individuals who publicly challenge the Pledge can expect cyclones of bloviation from elected leaders who, unwilling to fix healthcare or pay for infrastructure, always have time to defend the pledge or the flag. - Michael Lind

Could anything be more foreign to America's enlightened 18th-century liberal and republican traditions than this toxic compound of collectivism, nativism, Spartan militarism and theocracy? - Michael Lind

« Prev« Prev | Next »Next » Slideshow
77 comments
VIEWING:
 
Gooner82
Nov 17, 09 12:25 PM CST
Interesting way to look at it. People's heads here in Texas will explaode after reading this, but interesting nevertheless. Reply
Vote up! Vote down!
+35
IN RESPONSE:
Snowleopard
Nov 17, 09 2:48 PM CST
pledge of allegence = blind nationalism
Vote up! Vote down!
+9
IN RESPONSE:
Jayster999
Nov 17, 09 4:33 PM CST
There's nothing wrong with nationalism. America is a great country, with a great people and we owe much to our God and creator. We should acknowledge His hand in our success.
Vote up! Vote down!
-12
IN RESPONSE:
JonmarkP
Nov 17, 09 4:55 PM CST
We should shorten it: "I pledge allegiance to liberty and justice for all."
Vote up! Vote down!
+8
IN RESPONSE:
geneparmesan
Nov 17, 09 5:53 PM CST
'There's nothing wrong with nationalism' says the guy with Obama as Hitler? Use your brain much?
Vote up! Vote down!
+2
LEAVE A
COMMENT
Comment Policy
Facebook ConnectPost this comment to Facebook?

After connecting you will have the option to post your comment on your Facebook profile.

 

from our news partners

Please wait, content is loading
Please wait, content is loading

Just For Laughs

Loading...