After One-Star TripAdvisor Review, Restaurant Goes 'Nuclear'

Law firm for UK's High Rocks threatens mom Sarah Gardner with jail time
By Jenn Gidman,  Newser Staff
Posted May 19, 2017 7:50 AM CDT
Updated May 21, 2017 4:45 PM CDT
Mom's Scathing TripAdvisor Review Earns Her Jail Threat
High Rocks isn't taking Gardner's review sitting down.   (TripAdvisor)

A British mom says she's a "nervous wreck" after she posted a negative restaurant review on TripAdvisor and is now being threatened with jail time for libel and defamation, per the Mirror. The London Times reports on the situation of 44-year-old nurse Sarah Gardner, who put up a one-star review on the travel website for High Rocks, a Kent eatery she says had "rude" and "arrogant" staff and served fare that was "mediocre at best." High Rocks didn't appreciate the review and took what Gardner calls the "nuclear option," per the Mirror. It recruited a law firm, which sent her first an 11-page letter then a 14-page one noting her harsh words had cost the restaurant "financial harm worth tens of thousands of pounds."

She was warned she could be "imprisoned or fined" if she didn't send along dates and receipts of all the times she'd dined there. High Rocks wants those records because, after manager Giuseppe Cappellazzi accused Gardner of not dining there during the month she posted the review, she retorted she'd based her review on many High Rock experiences she'd had. Per the Times, Cappellazzi says she's being "vindictive" and that Gardner was just trying to get back at the restaurant because it refused to let her book it after she was "extremely rude and offensive" on the phone. Gardner insists her review was honest, but she asked TripAdvisor to take it down and says she's not sure what she'll do if her case is hauled into court. (This law firm didn't win its suit over a bad Yelp review.)

Get the news faster.
Tap to install our app.
Install the Newser News app
in two easy steps:
1. Tap in your navigation bar.
2. Tap to Add to Home Screen.