Critics agree on one thing when it comes to Charlie St. Cloud: Tween girls will love it, thanks to the number of times Zac Efron takes off his shirt. Beyond that they’re split, though the majority aren't enthusiastic:
- The movie, about a teen who loses his brother in a car accident, “tries to capture the crushing weight of loss, but between the insipid pop tunes and the repetitive shots cutting away to a lighthouse on a scenic outcropping, it feels more like a film version of a condolence card,” writes Claudia Puig in USA Today.
- “Zac Efron can act,” declares Rex Reed in the New York Observer, but the script “is so sappy you want to laugh.” Efron “deserves better movies than Charlie St. Cloud.”
- It's “a delicate film," Mick LaSalle writes for the San Francisco Chronicle, "that holds together on the strength of Efron's physical presence and performance."
- The film is inconsistent, writes James Berardinelli for ReelViews. It gives “the impression that the filmmakers are making things up as they go along, and a lot of those things don't make sense.”
For more on how Zac Efron has been spending his free time while waiting for the movie to premiere (hint: strippers), click here
. (Read more Charlie St. Cloud